diciembre, 2012

Bibliography

Ackroyd, P. (2006) The Complete Works of William Shakespeare. Glasgow: HarperCollins Publishers.

Anyó, J. (2004) Tirant lo Blanch I Shakespeare: les fonts de Much Ado About Nothing. Biblioteca Sanchis Guarner.

Arias Doblas, MºR. (1996) Gender ambiguity and desire in Twelfth Night. Universidad de Malaga.

Elizabeth R (2012) Elizabethan Women. [online] available from < http://www.elizabethi.org/us/women/> [27 November 2012]

Elizabethan-era.org (2012) Elizabethan Life. [online] available from < http://www.elizabethan-era.org.uk/elizabethan-life.htm> [28 November 2012]

Encyclopedia Britannica (2011) Encyclopedia Britannica’s Guide to Shakespeare[online] available from < http://www.britannica.com/shakespeare/article-232318> [26 November 2012]

Gay, P. (1994) As She Likes It: Shakespeare’s Unruly Woman. New York: Routledge. [online] available from < http://books.google.es/books?id=ia-JzEZnxlMC&printsec=frontcover&dq=feminism+in+much+ado+about+nothing&hl=es&sa=X&ei=3ZOjULzTK6bM0QWZxYCoBg&ved=0CDYQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=feminism%20in%20much%20ado%20about%20nothing&f=false> [28 November 2012]

GRIN Verlag (2008) Young Women in Shakespeare’s Comedies. Druck und Bindung: Books on Demand GmbH, Norderstedt Germany. [online] available from < http://books.google.es/books?id=k7SqKYsQbK4C&pg=PA37&dq=feminism+in+much+ado+about+nothing&hl=es&sa=X&ei=-LejUMeYOMeo0AXzyIDwAw&ved=0CDoQ6AEwAjgK#v=onepage&q=feminism%20in%20much%20ado%20about%20nothing&f=false> [28 November 2012]

GRIN Verlag (2007) Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night- Topicality as a Problem. Druck und Bindung: Books on Demand GmbH, Norderstedt Germany. [online] available from < http://books.google.es/books?id=2ejpKBW6HV0C&pg=PA6&dq=women+in+twelfth+night&hl=es&sa=X&ei=QnuqULfvHo6X0QXyv4HIAQ&ved=0CC4Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=women%20in%20twelfth%20night&f=false> [27 November 2012]

Goodman, L., De Gay, J. (1998) The Routledge Reader in Gender and Performance. New York: Routledge. [online] available from <http://books.google.es/books?id=a7LyV7Z-oRcC&pg=PA44&dq=feminism+in+much+ado+about+nothing&hl=es&sa=X&ei=3ZOjULzTK6bM0QWZxYCoBg&ved=0CEIQ6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=feminism%20in%20much%20ado%20about%20nothing&f=false> [27 November 2012]

Internet Shakespeare Editions (2011) Shakespeare’s life and Times [online] available from <http://internetshakespeare.uvic.ca/Library/SLT/intro/index.html> [26 November 2012]

Ruth Swift Lenz, C., Greene, G., Thomas Neely, C. (1983) The Woman’s Part: Feminist Criticism of Shakespeare. Illinois: Illini Books Editions. [online] available from <http://books.google.es/books?id=_6YmUoFcJsIC&printsec=frontcover&dq=feminism+in+much+ado+about+nothing&hl=es&sa=X&ei=-LejUMeYOMeo0AXzyIDwAw&ved=0CDcQ6AEwATgK#v=onepage&q&f=false > [27 November 2012]

Wikipedia (2012) Much Ado About Nothing [online] available from < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Much_Ado_About_Nothing> [29 November 2012]

Wikipedia (2012) The Taming of the Shrew [online] available from<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Taming_of_the_Shrew> [29 November 2012]

Wikipedia (2012) Twelfth Night [online] available from < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twelfth_night> [29 November 2012]

Wikipedia (2012) Shakespeare [online] available from<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shakespeare> [29 November 2012]

 

Conclusion

         To conclude with this paper, we are going to express some of the main ideas that we have gathered. We observed the importance of the values expressed by Shakespeare in three of his comedies, The Taming of the Shrew, Much Ado About Nothing and Twelfth Night, and we have compared how they were in the Elizabethan era and how audience could react upon them and how we can understand them in the 21th century. In this essay we have dealt with and analyse issues such as the arrangements of the economic marriages, the differences of social status and the position of women within the Elizabethan society.

          On the one hand, one of the topics studied here is the economic marriages as we mentioned above. We realise that during Shakespeare’s times, marriages were nothing else than an economic contract through which maintain the social status hierarchy. We want to highlight the importance of wealth, status and power during the decision of arranging the weddings, and the lack of voice that women had on them. However what we have seen here that thanks to the examples found in the three plays, is that Shakespeare as well portrayed the kind of marriage that we have got in general nowadays, the love marriage. We have seen how Bianca and Lucentio fall in love at first sight, as well as Claudio loves Hero in the right moment when he first saw her, and the love triangle created in Twelfth Night that finally ends in two happy love marriages.

          Moreover the differences among the diverse social status in society are another issue dealt within this paper. The Elizabethan period counted with a firm social hierarchy in which nobility was at the top of it and women and poor people at the lesser stage of it. Lives were so different depending in whether you belong to a high social class or whether you are at the bottom of the hierarchical pyramid. This topic is developed in differently in each one of the three comedies that we have chosen as examples of examination. We can see how these inequalities are treated with irony and satire in The Taming of the Shrew creating funny moments in which some of the characters pretend to be another person completely different of what they really are or even in the example of Christopher Sly when he is being confused by some people, making him believe that he is a nobleman when he is actually a drunken poor. On the other hand in the comedy Much Ado About Nothing, we can observe this social status differences as revenge as a result of the anxiety of power. This fact is represented by Don John, because of his envy of his brother’s social authority, and he uses his power with evil purposes in order to obtain more power. In Twelfth Night we are able to see the ambition of an economic marriage in order to rise up in the social hierarchy, represented by the character of Malvolio.

          Furthermore other issue present at the paper is the position of women. In Elizabethan period, the female image was conditioned by the masculine discourse of those who held the power of the word, culture, society and tradition. Female gender had no opportunity to be recognized as a true one which depends on the male world to justify their existence. The universe had a male point of view at all times, thus assuming the supremacy. Women had to act under the rules of that patriarchal society. However in these three Shakespearian comedies we have observed that there were different kinds of women, we can see Bianca, Hero or Olivia, the prototypical perfect ladies of the time, but Shakespeare shows as in addition some women who does not fit in the social conditions of the time, who act against the patriarchal rules such as Katherine and Beatrice on the one hand, who are considered as shrewish women, and Viola on the other hand, who has to portray herself as a man because she is aware that being a man would obtain wider possibilities than as being a woman.

Social differences

          The social reality of the Elizabethan Age was obviously marked by a contrast between a firm social hierarchy and at the same time the beginnings of flexibility within this hierarchy that concerned several layers of the contemporary audience. The Elizabethan society was organized according to a hierarchy as it is shown in Thomas Smith’s “De Republica Anglorum”: nobility, gentry, burgesses in the town, yeoman in the country, lesser men who did not rule. In addition women were seen as equal to the inferiors of this hierarchy (GRIN Verlag: 2008). So we can find the mixture of the medieval Feudal system which had broken down and which was built on a hierarchal pyramid system where everyone owed allegiance to their immediate superior and the nobles of the land and the Lords of the Manor were responsible for the peasants who lived on their land. On the other hand the outbreaks of the plague had reduced the population – even peasants were paid for their labour. The wool trade provided opportunities for Englishmen. There were opportunities for young Englishmen to become apprentices and learn a trade which would bring them a good standard of living. A Wealthy Merchant class was emerging in England. Elizabethan Daily life provided many opportunities which had been denied to previous generations. (Elizabethan-era.org: 2012)

         Daily life in Elizabethan England varied according to status and location. Many of the major elements of Elizabethan family life were determined by whether the family was poor and belonging to the lower classes or whether the family was wealthy. The main exception to this was religion, whether rich or poor, young or old, everyone in the family was expected to attend a Protestant Church Service every Sunday. Elizabethan family life was determined by the many laws of the land which dictated not only religion but also the types of clothes members of the family were allowed to wear. (Elizabethan-era.org: 2012)

        The kind of society that we have got nowadays is a product as a result of this change produced during the Elizabethan period, in which the feudal system was starting to be replaced by a new type of society in which the merchant class, the burgesses gained a lot of power even questioning the power of the nobility who was the class at the top of the hierarchy. However the differences among the social classes and the different status that population possess are still present nowadays, we have not been able to delete the injustices of the enormous economic differences of the citizens. Even more in this capitalistic time in which we live nowadays we can find this subjugation of the low classes to the ones that are at the top of this power hierarchy.

         As well as Shakespeare did with other values of the time as we have explained along this paper, he expresses these social differences in his plays. In The Taming of the Shrew, Much Ado About Nothing and Twelfth Night we can observe how he deals with this topic, but he treats it in a different way in each one of them.

         In the earliest of the three comedies we are dealing with here, we can observe the satire that Shakespeare uses in order to show the big social differences that existed at the Elizabethan period. He utilizes confusion as one of the main sources of humour. Just at the beginning of the play we have got in the induction act the example of Christopher Sly, a poor drunken man who is been used by a powerful man as his buffoon.  Sly is misled into believing that he is really a wealthy nobleman rather than a person belonging to the lowest social class stage of the social power hierarchy. This fact happens because when he returns in himself after the drunken night, he found himself in a luxury bedroom, wearing rich clothes and with a great number of servants assuring him he is a nobleman. So that we can realise how important was the kind of clothing, how it differentiates one kind of person from another one. So, wealth is just nothing more than showing off, as well as it happens nowadays.

SLY: Am I a lord, and have I such a lady?

Or do I dream? Or have I dreamed till now?

I do not sleep: I see, I hear, I speak.

I smell sweet savors and I feel soft things.

Upon my life, I am a lord indeed

And not a tinker, nor Christopher Sly.

Well, bring our lady hither to our sight,

And once again, a pot o’ the smallest ale.

(induction, II, 53-60)

         The following acts of the play have also got this kind of satire about the confusing personalities. By disguising themselves as other persons completely different than what they really are, some of the characters of The Taming of the Shrew create many funny moments in the comedy. Hortensio, one of the courtiers of Bianca at the beginning, pretends to be a music teacher called Litio as a technique to court Bianca. Moreover, Lucentio tries to use the same technique as Hortensio does, in order to captivate Bianca’s heart, and he disguises himself as a schoolmaster. Furthermore his servant, Tranio, pretends to be his master, portraying himself as a man of a higher social class to the one where he belongs.

BAPTISTA:A thousand thanks, Signior Gremio. Welcome, good

Cambio. (to TRANIO as LUCENTIO) But, gentle sir,

methinks you walk like a stranger. May I be so bold to

know the cause of your coming?

TRANIO: (as LUCENTIO) Pardon me, sir, the boldness is mine own,

That being a stranger in this city here

Do make myself a suitor to your daughter,

Unto Bianca, fair and virtuous.

Nor is your firm resolve unknown to me,

In the preferment of the eldest sister.

This liberty is all that I request,

That, upon knowledge of my parentage,

I may have welcome ’mongst the rest that woo

And free access and favor as the rest.

And toward the education of your daughters,

I here bestow a simple instrument

And this small packet of Greek and Latin books.

BIONDELLO brings the gifts forward

If you accept them, then their worth is great.

(2, I, 75-94)

 

          On the other hand, in the comedy Much Ado About Nothing, we can observe this social status differences as revenge as a result of the anxiety of power. This fact is represented by Don John, the bastard brother of Don Pedro, the king of Aragon. Don John is jealous of Claudio, a brave and virtuous gentleman, because he has replaced him in the benefits of the king, and he feels with more rights than him due to the kinship. So what he plans is to shame Claudio, by inventing the story of the window where Claudio thinks that Hero is losing her virginity with another man. He believes that by shaming Claudio, because of being engaged to woman that has lost her honour by not being chaste anymore, Don Pedro will reject him, and Don John will gain again the favour of the king. We see how he is the villain of the play and that he uses the power he has for evil purposes, just to obtain more social status, to be the favourite of the king because of his envy of his brother’s social authority.

DON JOHN: Come, come, let us thither. This may prove food to my

displeasure. That young start-up hath all the glory of my

overthrow. If I can cross him any way, I bless myself every

way. You are both sure, and will assist me?

(1, III, 50-53)

 

         Don Pedro is the character who is at the top of the social hierarchy of the play, he is the king, who has more power, and he knows it. However completely different as his villain brother does, he uses his power for positive purposes such as the courtly plot of Beatrice and Benedick.

DON PEDRO: And Benedick is not the unhopefulest husband that I know.

Thus far can I praise him: he is of a noble strain, of approved

valor, and confirmed honesty. I will teach you how to humor

your cousin that she shall fall in love with Benedick.—And

I, with your two helps, will so practice on Benedick

that, in despite of his quick wit and his queasy stomach, he

shall fall in love with Beatrice. If we can do this, Cupid is no

longer an archer; his glory shall be ours, for we are the only

love gods. Go in with me, and I will tell you my drift.

(2, I, 319-327)

 

          In the latter of the three comedies, Twelfth Night, we are able to see the ambition of an economic marriage in order to rise up in the social hierarchy, represented by the character of Malvolio. As we explained in the part of the marriages of this paper, Malvolio is Olivia’s servant, he is one of her closest servants but what we observe in the play is that he is very ambitious and that he pretends to marry her in order to rise out of his social class. He is shown as addicted to power over the others and he thinks himself as being superior to the other servants of the countess. As he explains in the play he sees himself as “Count Malvolio” (2, V, 30) when he marries her. However reality is completely different and Olivia does not want to marry her because she is in love of Cesario and moreover it was not typical at the Elizabethan period that a woman of her social status would marry a servant of a lower status than her.

Women in Twelfth Night

          In the Shakespearian comedy Twelfth Night, as well as it happens in the other two comedies that we are analysing in this paper, we observe that the author gave a great importance to women, they are the main characters of the story and we see two differentiated kind of women, one brave and wise, Viola, and the other viewed as emotional, irrational and petty, Olivia. However this Shakespearian comedy, believed as one of the last comedies he wrote, has a big difference compared to the other two, it appears in it a women disguised as a men. This woman is Viola, a courageous woman who after a shipwreck, she arrives at an unknown place, thinking that she has lost her brother on the accident. So knowing the fact that she is a woman and the kind of opportunities that she would have in that new place, she decides to disguise herself as a man. So that we can say that this comedy is one of the so-called transvestite comedies of Shakespeare. A woman has to pretend to be a man in order to have recognition and to obtain wider opportunities in society. As it was the ‘period of change’, this play could have been written to change people’s ideas of females and males in general.

VIOLA: Oh, that I served that lady

And might not be delivered to the world,

Till I had made mine own occasion mellow,

What my estate is.

CAPTAIN:That were hard to compass,

Because she will admit no kind of suit,

No, not the duke’s.

VIOLA: There is a fair behavior in thee, captain,

And though that nature with a beauteous wall

Doth oft close in pollution, yet of thee

I will believe thou hast a mind that suits

With this thy fair and outward character.

I prithee—and I’ll pay thee bounteously—

Conceal me what I am, and be my aid

For such disguise as haply shall become

The form of my intent. I’ll serve this duke.

Thou shall present me as an eunuch to him.

It may be worth thy pains, for I can sing

And speak to him in many sorts of music

That will allow me very worth his service.

What else may hap to time I will commit.

Only shape thou thy silence to my wit.

(1, II, 38-53)

          Both female characters are given power although it is different to them. On the one hand Olivia represents the typical female women, she is young daughter of a count who died one year before the action of the play, and she has been guarded by her brother, but he died as well. Now she is a single woman who has no man who takes care of her and she has made a kind of a promise in memory of her brother, so that she is now living as a recluse at home without receiving any visit from men. It is like the idea of a woman of the time that doesn’t want to marry and becomes a nun. She is very emotional and irrational; however she has got lot of power over the people who live at his house working for her as we can see in some passages when she gives orders to them: «let the garden door be shut and leave me to my hearing» (3.I.92-94). On the other hand Viola, the other main female character, obtains power when she disguises as a man, Cesario, and gains the trust of Duke Orsino. Here we have got a proof of this social difference between women and men a fact that Shakespeare does in order to show to the reader how the same person and the same ideas are received in different ways by society only because of the gender of that person. In order to find a way of making women speak, without letting them look immodest as Beatrice and Katherine looked like, they had to wear men’s clothes as Viola did (GRIN Verlag: 2008).

          This act of disguising is one of the most important within the plot of the play and one of the most commented and analysed by the critics. Thus, Viola, dresses up as Cesario, so as to pass safely through this new land, leading to a great number of mistaken-identity moments. Inevitably, she founds then herself trapped in a strange love triangle between the duke she serves and loves and the countess she is wooing on his behalf, who naturally falls in love with her, thinking that she is a man. This disguising game allows the characters to explore new possibilities that the rules of society of that age would have never allowed such as the love that Olivia feels for a woman, despite she thinks she is a man, or the love of Viola for Orsino, that she sometimes almost revealed but that she maintained secretly because they were supposed to be two men and that was not accepted. However in the right moment when she reveals the truth, he immediately confesses his love for her.

ORSINO: (to OLIVIA) Be not amazed. Right noble is his blood.

If this be so, as yet the glass seems true,

I shall have share in this most happy wreck.

(to VIOLA) Boy, thou hast said to me a thousand times

Thou never shouldst love woman like to me.

VIOLA: And all those sayings will I overswear;

And those swearings keep as true in soul

As doth that orbèd continent the fire

That severs day from night.

ORSINO: Give me thy hand,

And let me see thee in thy woman’s weeds.

(5, I 257-270)

ORSINO: Madam, I am most apt to embrace your offer.

(to VIOLA)

Your master quits you, and for your service done him,

So much against the mettle of your sex,

So far beneath your soft and tender breeding,

And since you called me “master” for so long,

Here is my hand. You shall from this time be

Your master’s mistress.

(5, I, 312-318)

Women in Much Ado About Nothing

          In this romantic comedy we can see that the principal characters are women as well as in The Taming of the Shrew and Twelfth Night, and that the main plot turns around them. Shakespeare created in Much Ado About Nothing two different women as he did in The Taming of the Shrew with Katherine and Bianca. Here we have got Beatrice, a revel, virtuous and wise women and her cousin Hero, passive, shadowy and almost silent. Shakespeare again portraits the values of a typical lady of the Elizabethan era through the figure of Hero and the antithesis of it with the courageous Beatrice. After the reading of this comedy, I believe that we could say that it is a kind of rewriting of The Taming of the Shrew due to the similar plot, characters and facts that take place in both of them.

          Making a comparison between the two plays, we observe lots of resemblances between Beatrice and Katherine, both share a shrewish character because they don’t want to follow the rules and to adapt a submissive attitude of women at Elizabethan time, they don’t want to get married with any man and one of their powerful weapons is their voice, they react against what they think that are injustices and they fight to be considered as equal as men.

BEATRICE: A dear happiness to women. They would else have been

troubled with a pernicious suitor. I thank God and my cold

blood I am of your humor for that. I had rather hear my dog

bark at a crow than a man swear he loves me.

(1, I, 103-106)

 

         These words said by Beatrice above remind us like they kind of rude speech that we read in The Taming of the Shrew when Katherine talked. Beatrice is like the new version of Katherine.

 

LEONATO: Well, niece, I hope to see you one day fitted with a husband.

BEATRICE: Not till God make men of some other metal than

earth. Would it not grieve a woman to be

overmastered with a pierce of valiant dust? to make

an account of her life to a clod of wayward marl?

No, uncle, I’ll none: Adam’s sons are my brethren;

and, truly, I hold it a sin to match in my kindred.

(2, I, 48-53)

 

          However, although Katherine and Beatrice reject marriage at first, both women finally ends up being married. The difference between them is that while Katherine is being forced to marry Petruchio, and a great part of the comedy is based on the process of taming after the wedding, Beatrice marries Benedick after a complicate process of courtship. One of the main points here is that she is not forced by any male authority to marry any man, she is a strong female character and she marries only after asserting her dislike for the traditionally minor role of women in marriage and courtship in that time, and she finds it in Benedick, who at the beginning of the play was as well against marriage as she was.

          Despite the similarities of these characters that we are comparing, they differ at some points. One of them is that in contrast to the bad temper and the sadness of Katherine, Beatrice is happy and friendly:

DON PEDRO: By my troth, a pleasant-spirited lady.

LEONATO: There’s little of the melancholy element in her, my lord. She

is never sad but when she sleeps, and not ever sad then, for

I have heard my daughter say she hath often dreamed of

unhappiness and waked herself with laughing.

(2, I, 288-292)

 

          On the other hand the opposite female main character of this romantic comedy, Hero, can be compared to Bianca from The Taming of the Shrew because they have got a very similar character according to the values of the 16th century’s ladies. They both are almost quiet along the play and here, in contrast to Beatrice, Hero is under the caring of her father, he is who has to decide if the man that courts his daughter is good enough for her.

DON PEDRO: I’ faith, lady, I think your blazon to be true, though, I’ll be

sworn, if he be so, his conceit is false.—Here, Claudio, I

have wooed in thy name, and fair Hero is won. I have broke

with her father and his goodwill obtained. Name the day of

marriage, and God give thee joy.

(2, I, 249-253)

 

          One of the main plots of this comedy is around the wedding commented before between Hero and her fiancé Claudio. After a confusing moment when he believes he is seeing Hero having relationships with another man, he renounces her in the middle of the ceremony and humiliates her accusing her of losing virginity with another man. So with this example we can see the importance of virginity and chastity of women. This topic has remained very important in our society until the last few years, it is closed related to religious ideals and imposed to society. In Shakespeare’s times the honor of a woman depended on her virginity, so that having sexual relationships before marriage was the synonym of losing her honour and dignity and as well of the whole family. In this case it was even worst because she was supposed to have sexual relationships with other man than her fiancé. So this is the reason why both Claudio and Leonato directed her so cruel words, because they were disappointed with her and for her dishonest attitude. Claudio shamed her at the wedding ceremony telling everyone she was not a virgin anymore:

CLAUDIO: Marry, that can Hero!

Hero itself can blot out Hero’s virtue.

What man was he talked with you yesternight

Out at your window betwixt twelve and one?

Now, if you are a maid, answer to this.

(4, I, 79,83)

 

         Her father also directed strong words to her because she had disappointed all the family:

LEONATO: Wherefore! Why, doth not every earthly thing

Cry shame upon her? Could she here deny

The story that is printed in her blood?—

Do not live, Hero, do not ope thine eyes,

For, did I think thou wouldst not quickly die,

Thought I thy spirits were stronger than thy shames,

Myself would, on the rearward of reproaches,

Strike at thy life. Grieved I I had but one?

Chid I for that at frugal Nature’s frame?

O, one too much by thee! Why had I one?

Why ever wast thou lovely in my eyes?

Why had I not with charitable hand

Took up a beggar’s issue at my gates,

Who, smirchèd thus, and mired with infamy,

I might have said, “No part of it is mine;

This shame derives itself from unknown loins”?

(4, I, 119-134)

Women in the Taming of the Shrew

          In the early and revolutionary Shakespearian comedy The Taming of the Shrew, the role of women becomes a battle of the sexes. The most characteristic of this Elizabethan work on the issue we are dealing with, is the fact that the main character in the play is a woman. As we expressed in the First Paper, Shakespeare created in this play a rude and rebellious character, in contrast to the values of the lady of the period. In this case, we develop a parallelism between Bianca, a beautiful, polite and obedient woman and her sister Katherine, a woman with radical character as we can see in verses like “Katherine: her silence flouts me, and I´ll be reveng´d [flies after Bianca]”( 2, I, 20-25). It is to say, the author reflects on these two women the definition and the antithesis of correct behavior of Elizabethan women according to the society of the period.

KATHERINE: I’ faith, sir, you shall never need to fear.

I wis it is not halfway to her heart.

But if it were, doubt not her care should be

To comb your noddle with a three-legged stool

And paint your face and use you like a fool.

(1, I, 61-65)

 

          In this play we can observe the comparison between the perfect woman who is submissive and obedient and which is guided by the male figure of her family, with a wild and rebellious woman that, as we have said, stands out as the opposition to these feminine values in the 16th century. However despite her shrewdness, both women in the play are controlled by the rules of Elizabethan society because they are dependent on a male figure and who have no voice at first sight. One of the examples is that both women, specially Katheriene who is forced to marry Petruchio against her will, finally got married with a man, but after the acceptance of their father, he was who has the last decision on their acts, in fact at the beginning of the play he is looking for a fiancé for her daughter Katherine because he didn’t allow Bianca to get married until the older of his daughters were married.

BAPTISTA: Gentlemen, importune me no farther,

For how I firmly am resolved you know—

That is, not to bestow my youngest daughter

Before I have a husband for the elder.

If either of you both love Katherina,

Because I know you well and love you well

Leave shall you have to court her at your pleasure.

(1, I, 48-54)

 

          The fact that a woman is the main character of a play in the 16th century such as the one that we are discussing here, helps to support the argument that we were introducing previously in the paper, women are important in Shakespeare’s plays. Although it is certain that he tries to reflect the society of his period as is demonstrated at the end of the play, when Kate lost her own battle marrying Petruchio and reciting her monologue which acclaim the values characteristics of a woman of the Elizabethan period, it can be interpreted as a feministic point of view of Shakespeare because with this resource he is showing the audience in which kind of society they live so that they can react against the injustices.

Women in Shakespeare’s comedies

         Compared to other writers of his time, Shakespeare introduces an unusual amount of deep female characters in his comedies. His representation of women, in particular the ways in which his female roles are interpreted and put on stage, have become topics of scientific interest. Especially the young women of them show vitality, great intelligence and a strong sense of personal independence, which marks them as “queens of comedy”. (GRIN Verlag: 2007) As we stated in the previous paper, the position of the women in society is one of the universal values that are reflected on Shakespearian comedies. He portrayed in his plays different kinds of women, many of them as we read few lines above with much more characteristics of the 20th century women than to the prototypical lady of the Elizabethan period. So that we can affirm that Shakespeare tried to represent the women of the future, the women with the right they should have as equal to men as they actually are.

          In order to know a little about the period in which Shakespeare lived so that we can understand better what he portrayed in his plays and what he wanted to show to the audience, we can make an introduction about the Elizabethan period related to the treat of women and men, which is the topic we are going to deal with in this section. Even though there was an unmarried woman on the throne in Elizabethan England, the roles of women in society were very limited. The Elizabethans had very clear expectations of men and women, and in general men were expected to be the breadwinners and women to be housewives and mothers. Elizabethan society was patriarchal, meaning that men were considered to be the leaders and women their inferiors. Women were regarded as «the weaker sex», not just in terms of physical strength, but emotionally too.  It was believed that women always needed someone to look after them. If they were married, their husband was expected to look after them. If they were single, then their father, brother or another male relative was expected to take care of them. (Elizabeth R: 2012)

          One consistent feature of Shakespearian dramas- not just for comedy- is that it proceeds by way of inversion of the norms of behaviour, we can call them figures of excess. The examples we can clear show about the comedies we are analising in this paper are Katherine and Beatrice who act like a shrew rejecting to behave as the prototypical lady of the time and negating to be married, and Viola  who disguises herself as a man in order to widen her possibilities in the new place where she arrived.

          We are invited to contemplate a changing image of “woman” for whom a refusal of the codes of femininity offers exciting possibilities for the liberation of physical, psychic and erotic energy. This inversion of the roles provide the female main characters of these comedies with an incredible power that allow them to do many things that they wouldn’t be allowed to do according to the rules of the Elizabethan period.

          Shakespeare in his plays reinforces the patriarchal status quo of the Elizabethan society and he shows us both the prototypical lady of the era and the rebel woman who reacts against the stereotypes of the age because she doesn’t agree with the rules that just minimize the woman. So probably what Shakespeare tried to do was to offer an image to the audience about what kind of world they were living in, so that people can react about what society was really doing with women, he was showing the dominant hopes and fears of the society to which their plays were represented. With this portraying of the world, the author hopped to change society for the better through theatre’s playful transgression. (Gay:1994) Thus William Shakespeare in portraying witty and high-spirited heroines transcends patriarchal social prejudices about women and sees men and women as equal in a world which declared them unequal. (GRIN Verlag: 2008)

          In order to develop these statements we are going to apply them to the comedies The Taming of the Shrew, Much Ado About Nothing and Twelfth Night, which we have read in order to write this essay, so we will provide examples of them to make clearer what we have written above.

Marriages in Twelfth Night

          In the comedy Twelfth Night we can find as well as in the two previous plays that we are analising, this multiple happy endings as a result of the numerous couples produced. Olivia and Sebastian, Orsino and Viola and Sir Toby and Maria finally end up marrying. However the two first couples, have suffered during the evolution of the play different confusing moments due to the shipwreck, the supposing death of Sebastian and the disguising of Viola into Cesario.

         As a romantic comedy, one of the main factors that we find in it is love and many of the marriages produced are based on it rather than on an economical matrimony. The main difference that we have got here is the amusing love triangle produced along the comedy due to the fact that Viola disguises as a man so she founds herself loving her master Orsino to whom she cannot tell her love for him due to she pretends to be a man, and trying to woo a woman, Olivia, for him, which falls in love in the same moment when she sees Cesario, who in fact is Viola, a woman. So one of the main topics of this comedy is this cross gendered loves that could not be accepted at that time. We find that Olivia despite thinking is in love with Cesario, a brave man of Orsino, she is really in love with a woman, a fact that cannot be possible in the Elizabethan period. On the other hand, Viola cannot confess to Orsino what she really feels for him because she is supposed to be a man and a love between people of the same sex was considered abominable in the 16th century. However what we really find here is that what they three feel is real love, they are not concerned in economic purposes or in getting power as the other arranged marriages of the time.

         One of the facts that can prove this real love is the kind of suffering of Orsino that we observe at the play because of the numerous rejections from part of Olivia, the woman he is really in love with. He tries several times to send messages to her in order to convince her that he wants to marry her.

CAPTAIN: And so is now, or was so very late.

For but a month ago I went from hence,

And then ’twas fresh in murmur—as, you know,

What great ones do the less will prattle of—

That he did seek the love of fair Olivia.

(1, II, 27- 31)

ORSINO: (to VIOLA and attendants)

Stand you a while aloof. (to VIOLA) Cesario,

Thou know’st no less but all. I have unclasped

To thee the book even of my secret soul.

Therefore, good youth, address thy gait unto her;

Be not denied access, stand at her doors,

And tell them there thy fixed foot shall grow

Till thou have audience.

(1, IV, 11-18)

 

ORSINO: O, then unfold the passion of my love,

Surprise her with discourse of my dear faith:

It shall become thee well to act my woes;

She will attend it better in thy youth

Than in a nuncio’s of more grave aspect.

(1, IV, 24-28)

         Moreover we can see how Olivia, who was supposed to be confined at home during some years in order to cry the death of her brother, fall in love without wishing it after having a conversation with Cesario (Viola disguised) the servant of the Duke, and how after this moment she will want to know more about him and finally would ask him for marriage. She doesn´t mind if he is from a lower class than her, she has just fall in love or as she says in this passage: “she has catch the plague”.

OLIVIA: “What is your parentage?”

“Above my fortunes, yet my state is well.

I am a gentleman.” I’ll be sworn thou art;

Thy tongue, thy face, thy limbs, actions, and spirit,

Do give thee fivefold blazon. Not too fast! Soft, soft!

Unless the master were the man. How now?

Even so quickly may one catch the plague?

Methinks I feel this youth’s perfections

With an invisible and subtle stealth

To creep in at mine eyes. Well, let it be.—

What ho, Malvolio!

(1, V, 263-273)

         As well as we see this pain produced by love in Orsino and Olivia, Viola shows her feeling about the love she feels for Orsino and the love problems created as a result of her disguising:

VIOLA: None of my lord’s ring? Why, he sent her none.

I am the man. If it be so, as ’tis,

Poor lady, she were better love a dream.

Disguise, I see thou art a wickedness,

Wherein the pregnant enemy does much.

How easy is it for the proper false

In women’s waxen hearts to set their forms!

Alas, our frailty is the cause, not we,

For such as we are made of, such we be.

How will this fadge? My master loves her dearly,

And I, poor monster, fond as much on him,

And she, mistaken, seems to dote on me.

What will become of this? As I am man,

My state is desperate for my master’s love.

As I am woman, now, alas the day,

What thriftless sighs shall poor Olivia breathe!

O time, thou must untangle this, not I.

It is too hard a knot for me to untie!

(2, II, 22-39)

 

         On the other hand, as well as we find different types of marriage in The Taming of the Shrew and in Much Ado About Nothing, here we have got this mixture between the real love marriages shown above and the prototypical economical marriages of the Elizabethan period. In this case the main character which represents this concern about money and power is Malvolio, Olivia’s servant, who is pretending to marry her but just for motifs of power. With this example we can see how marriage was a means o increasing one’ status in Elizabethan society.

MALVOLIO: ‘Tis but fortune, all is fortune. Maria once told me she

did affect me, and I have heard herself come thus near,

that, should she fancy, it should be one of my

complexion. Besides, she uses me with a more exalted

respect than anyone else that follows her. What should I think on ’t?

(2, V, 20-24)

 

MALVOLIO: To be Count Malvolio!

(2, V, 30)

 

As we can see, Malvolio has just aspirations of power in the process of marrying; he is not concerned about love.

Marriages in Much Ado About Nothing

          As well as it happened in the play commented before, in the romantic comedy Much Ado About Nothing , Shakespeare created a double love plot which remind us The Taming of the Shrew and that ends with a double happy ending with the union of the couples Hero-Claudio and Beatrice- Benedick. However these two relationships are develop in the comedy in a different way. Claudio’s courtship of Hero and their love is much closed to the one of Bianca and Lucentio, in addition we can compare as well the strange relationship between Beatrice and Benedick with the shrewish Katherine and her husband Petruchio, however in the former couple the process of taming is carried on the two members of the couple, due to both of them were completely against marriage.

          I believe that Shakespeare purpouse in the Hero-Claudio plot is not just to show us the anti-romantic aspects of an arranged marriage but rather to confront the psychological difficulties of joining the traditional arranged marriage, which takes into account social economic reality, with romantic and erotic love marriage between equals in which neither partner was idealized nor degraded and would thus constitute a new ideal relationship, one rooted in the reciprocity of mutuality. (Ruth Swift Lenz, Greene, Thomas Neely: 1983). So that we can observe in this marriage a mixture of both types of love, on the one hand we appreciate examples of the typical courtship and the appropriate arrangements of the wedding. As we can observe in this example, the term used when Claudio is referring of couting Hero because he like her, is “to buy”, a word that has nothing to be with a love marriage, and that shows us how a man can obtain a woman, to buy her, referring to a women as an object that can be sold and bought:

BENEDICK: Would you buy her, that you enquire after her?

CLAUDIO: Can the world buy such a jewel?

(1, I, 140-141)

          Moreover the marriage is not arranged until Don Pedro talks to Leonato and he accepts and gives permission to her daughter to marry Claudio, a typical process of the economical arranged marriages:

DON PEDRO: I’ faith, lady, I think your blazon to be true, though, I’ll be

sworn, if he be so, his conceit is false.—Here, Claudio, I

have wooed in thy name, and fair Hero is won. I have broke

with her father and his goodwill obtained. Name the day of

marriage, and God give thee joy.

(2, I, 249-253)

 

          Furthermore Claudio knows that Hero is the only heir that Leonato has, so he is concerned that all the fourtune that Leonato possesses will be his in the future when he marries Hero, so it can be seen as well as a proof of the importance money in marriages:

CLAUDIO:Hath Leonato any son, my lord?

DON PEDRO: No child but Hero; she’s his only heir.

Dost thou affect her, Claudio?

CLAUDIO: O, my lord,

When you went onward on this ended action,

I looked upon her with a soldier’s eye,

That liked but had a rougher task in hand

Than to drive liking to the name of love.

But now I am returned and that war thoughts

Have left their places vacant, in their rooms

Come thronging soft and delicate desires,

All prompting me how fair young Hero is,

Saying I liked her ere I went to wars.

(1, I, 232-243)

 

          As we can observe in this last part of the fragment shown above, Claudio reflects his loving interests in Hero, he affirms that his thoughts have to do with war and his feelings with desire of Hero. In the right moment when he first sees her, he realizes that she is a fair woman, she is both beautiful and unsullied. He shows us that his interest in Hero is just not for a business marriage, he is really in love for her and she loves him as well.

CLAUDIO: In mine eye she is the sweetest lady that ever I looked on.

(1, I, 146)

 

CLAUDIO: That I love her, I feel.

(1, I, 179)

          In fact when Claudio realizes about the loss of virginity of Hero, he feels wounded not only for the fact that his future wife was no chaste anymore but for the pain he feels thinking of her with another men, he is ill about the betrayal of his love. Moreover we can see the difference in Claudio between when he was planning his wedding with Hero, that he was anxious and that he didn’t want to wait for a long to be Hero’s husband, and the second wedding in which he has to marry Leonato’s niece penitent for the death of Hero when he asks “Which is the lady I must seize upon?”(5, IV, 53). With this example Shakespeare shows us that he was really in love with Hero and that now he has to marry a masked woman, which reveals that this marriage was a social institution that has nothing to do with love.

          On the other hand we have got in Much Ado About Nothing the Beatrice and Benedick plot. As we explained before it remind us the Katherine and Petruchio story, however here the process of taming takes place in both man and woman, due to no one of them wanted to get married. We see Beatrice as the new version of Katherine’ shrewish behavior against her possible suitors however the former with a better attitude to the rest of the people as we explained in the part of the position of women. In this case, Benedick is as shrew as Beatrice is. At the beginning of the play we can observe how against of marriage and love he is. The following excerpt is what he answers when Don Pedro says that he finally will fall in love with a woman:

BENEDICK: Is ’t come to this? In faith, hath not the world one man but

he will wear his cap with suspicion? Shall I never see a

bachelor of three-score again? Go to, i’ faith, an thou wilt

needs thrust thy neck into a yoke, wear the print of it, and

sigh away Sundays. Look, Don Pedro is returned to seek

you.

(1, I, 154-159)

 

         However they both finally fall in love with other and change their mind completely about love, after a process of false discourses that both Benedick’s and Beatrice’s friends prepare in order to make them believe that the other one has confessed to be in love with the other. This “cupid” process is realized by the play within the play that Shakespeare uses in the comedy in which the actors a part from doing their job of acting a character have to act within the play.

          What we can say about the marriages in Much Ado About Nothing that takes place between Hero and Claudio and Beatrice and Benedick have no dynastic paradigm as other marriages of some Shakespearian comedies, because neither Claudio nor Benedick shows no desire to govern anywhere.

Marriages in The Taming of the Shrew

         In the Shakespearian comedy The Taming of the Shrew, we can observe both types of marriages of the era. On the one hand there is Lucentio’s courtship of Bianca which is based on love at first sight. Lucentio falls in love in the same moment when he sees the perfect Bianca appearing in front of him, he immediately thinks she is the perfect women for him. So that we can say that the purpose of his courtship is to get married with the woman he loves, nothing to be with economic reasons. On the other hand, there is as well Petruchio’s wooing which is driven by money, despite at the end of the comedy it seems that both Kate and Petruchio are really in love. At the beginning of the play we can see he is only concerned with money, he doesn’t care about the woman who will be his wife, neither if she really wanted to marry him or not.

LUCENTIO: (aside to TRANIO) But in the other’s silence do I see

Maid’s mild behavior and sobriety.

Peace, Tranio.

(1, I 71-73)

LUCENTIO: Listen Tranio! That’s Minerva’s voice you hear.

(1, I, 86)

TRANIO: I pray, sir, tell me, is it possible

That love should of a sudden take such hold?

LUCENTIO: O Tranio, till I found it to be true,

I never thought it possible or likely.

But see, while idly I stood looking on,

I found the effect of love in idleness

And now in plainness do confess to thee

That art to me as secret and as dear

As Anna to the Queen of Carthage was,

Tranio, I burn, I pine, I perish, Tranio,

If I achieve not this young modest girl.

Counsel me, Tranio, for I know thou canst.

Assist me, Tranio, for I know thou wilt.

(1, I, 117-129)

 

PETRUCHIO: Such wind as scatters young men through the world

To seek their fortunes farther than at home,

Where small experience grows. But in a few,

Signior Hortensio, thus it stands with me:

Antonio, my father, is deceased,

And I have thrust myself into this maze,

Happily to wive and thrive as best I may.

Crowns in my purse I have and goods at home,

And so am come abroad to see the world.

HORTENSIO: Petruchio, shall I then come roundly to thee

And wish thee to a shrewd, ill-favored wife?

Thou’dst thank me but a little for my counsel;

And yet I’ll promise thee she shall be rich,

And very rich. But thou’rt too much my friend,

And I’ll not wish thee to her.

PETRUCHIO: Signior Hortensio, ’twixt such friends as we

Few words suffice. And therefore, if thou know

One rich enough to be Petruchio’s wife,

As wealth is burden of my wooing dance,

Be she as foul as was Florentius’ love,

As old as Sibyl and as curst and shrewd

As Socrates’ Xanthippe, or a worse,

She moves me not, or not removes at least

Affection’s edge in me, were she as rough

As are the swelling Adriatic seas.

I come to wive it wealthily in Padua;

If wealthily, then happily in Padua.

(1, II, 36-62)

          In order to get married with their women, both suitors have to arrange the dowry of the marriage, so even though love was the principal factor for marring as in the case of the Bianca and Lucentio’ story, money was so important, because as we can see in the play, Lucentio finally gets the permission for marring Bianca however it is just only after assuring him that he was rich enough for her daughter. Thus we see how women were essentially the means of exchange in power relationships. As Stone suggests “Elizabethan marriages were negotiated by the parents; at most, children were given the right of veto” (Ruth Swift Lenz, Greene, Thomas Neely: 1983). Shakespeare in this comedy emphasises the economic aspects of marriage of the patriarchal society of the time.

          In addition one of the main aspects that differences this comedy with the rest of the comedies Shakespeare wrote is that it doesn’t end with the wedding ceremony, but it continues showing us the marital life. In this case it corresponds with the taming process in which Petruchio with some outrageous practices tries to correct his shrewish wife in order to turn her into the perfect wife of the period. With this process we can observe that marriage was an important institution in Elizabethan times to ensure the social fixed order.

          Moreover we can say that concerning this topic of marriages, Shakespeare introduces in The Taming of the Shrew, as well as in many other comedies as we will see later, a source which provides various happy endings to the play that is that the comedy doesn’t end with a single marriage but with the union of a number of happy couples, in this case Bianca and Lucentio, Katherine and Petruchio and Hortensio with the widow.

LUCENTIO: At last, though long, our jarring notes agree,

And time it is when raging war is done

To smile at ’scapes and perils overblown.

My fair Bianca, bid my father welcome,

While I with selfsame kindness welcome thine.

Brother Petruchio, sister Katherina,

And thou, Hortensio, with thy loving widow,

Feast with the best, and welcome to my house.

My banquet is to close our stomachs up,

After our great good cheer. Pray you, sit down,

For now we sit to chat as well as eat.

(5, I, 1-11)

Página siguiente »