The position of women
Another of the values represented in Shakespeare’s plays is the position of women in society. During that time women were treated inferior to men. From childhood they were taught to obey the orders of men in the house and they did not have the same rights as men. If they ever disobeyed orders of any male member of the family, they were punished because that was seen as a crime according to what religion told them. Women could not inherit the tittles that their fathers had, but these passed from father to son. In contrast, the queen at that time in England was a woman and in addition she was unmarried. This happened because there was no choice when the father and the brother of Elizabeth I died. Nowadays the concept of women in society has changed considerably thanks to the struggle of women to show that we have the same rights and duties as men, because after all we are both, women and men, people. However there are still some remnants of the old patriarchal ideology. Today women can make decisions alone without the necessity of help of any man and can also access the important jobs as ministers or prime minister. (Internet Shakespeare Editions: 2011)
There are examples of the difference between the women of the Elizabethan era and the women in the 20th in the Shakespeare’s play The Taming of the Shrew and its adaptation to television made by the BBC in 2005. In the theatre play we can see how women are relegated to second place. Baptista, the father of Bianca and Katherine exercise the authority and is in charge of finding a husband for them. Moreover if he cannot find any man that wants to marry his oldest daughter he will not allow the youngest to do so. In addition even though the main character is a woman, the man is who finally have the power and dominates as happened at that time. The title of the play already gives us an idea of how society in that moment saw the women, Katherine is called the shrew, which is the way that are called the women who are nonconformist and a bit different (oxforddictionaries:2012).
In the TV adaptation of the play we can see how the role of women is different. Kate has an important job in British society, she is politician and she wants to become the leader of the opposition with the aim of becoming the prime minister. Bianca is a famous model who is very successful throughout the world. Moreover a big change is that the character of Baptista in the play is done by the mother of the girls in the mini-series. The fact that is the mother and not the father who appears in the film with Katherine and Bianca shows us that currently the 16th century patriarchal society no longer exists and it is not only the father who can make decisions about their daughters but also mother helping and giving advice to their daughters about their lives. In addition unlike the play, Bianca is going to flirt with Lucentio, which also shows that nowadays does not exist the concept that it is man who has to be a gallant and conquer the woman, but she can also take the initiative to do it. Despite this the end of the movie is the same, Petruchio tame the shrew by treating her the same way as she treats others.
However this ending has been asked and studied because it is not clear if Katherine really gets tamed at the end by Petruchio or if she is just acting when she speaks her last monologue.
“Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,
Thy head, thy sovereign . . .
Such duty as the subject owes the prince,
Even such a woman oweth to her husband,
And when she is froward, peevish, sullen, sour,
And not obedient to his honest will,
What is she but a foul contending rebel
And graceless traitor to her loving lord?
I am ashamed that women are so simple [foolish]
To offer war where they should kneel for peace,
Or seek for rule, supremacy, and sway,
When they are bound to serve, love, and obey.”
(5.2.148-66).
That is, Shakespeare is not defending the value of inferiority of women, but just trying to show the injustices that women had to suffer in this time beacause wether or not she really belives what she says in the example above, she has to tell it in order to behave as a proper wife. We will explain this issue in the part of the paper where we want to debate the possible or not misogynistic view of Shakespeare.
Comments(0)