Marriages in Shakespeare’s comedies

          Just as today, in the 16th century, a woman’s wedding was one of the most important days of her life. The major difference to Elizabethan wedding customs to a modern day Western marriage is that the woman had very little, if any, choice in who her husband might be (Elizabethan-era.org:2012). As we explained in the section of the position of women of this paper, Elizabethan woman were raised to believe that they were inferior to men and that they were always dependent on a male figure, the father during the period of childhood and their husband after the wedding. Marriages would be arranged to bring prestige or wealth to the family, so that both families involved would benefit. Many couples would meet for the very first time on their wedding day.

          So that we can say that marriages in Elizabethan time were like an economic contract more than a relationship based on love as it happens nowadays, when we are free to choose our future husband according to what our heart dictates us. However this is the general rule but, both in the Elizabethan period and nowadays, exceptions occur so that we can find some love marriages instead of an economical institution during the 16th century and some marriages based on money and power in the 21th century. In this part of the paper we will provide some fragments of the three comedies of Shakespeare that we are analysing here, The Taming of the Shrew, Much Ado About Nothing and Twelfth Night, in order to exemplify what we have just said above.

Introduction

          As we stated in the first paper: ‘Shakespeare embodies universal values and has something to say to all people at all times and in all places’ (Eaglestone 2000:67). This is one of the reasons why this author of the 16th century is still so important and famous nowadays. In his works he expressed a great number of universal values such as religion, power, revenge, love or customs. However one of the facts that differences him from other authors of his time, is that at the same time he reflected the Elizabethan society in which he lived and he portrayed as well with this values a kind of society that was the reference of the society in which we live actually, so we can understand all the issues that Shakespeare wanted to show to his audience. Obviously some aspects of the prototypical live of the 16th century have change during this four centuries that separate ourselves from Shakespeare but this fact has not affected the magnificent work that he produced. Today, in the 21th century, most of the population knows who is Shakespeare, has read some fragments of any of his works, has listen his name or at least has heard one of the most famous sentences of his play Hamlet: “To be or not to be, that is the question” (3, I).

          In this paper we want to show the importance of the universal values that he reflected such as the kind of marriages that were arranged and which were the purposes of them, the differences that existed among the social classes of the time and what are the results that it produced and the position that women had during that time due to the existing rules about women and men, taking examples from the comedies The Taming of the Shrew, Much Ado About Nothing and Twelfth Night, in order to make clearer the concepts that we are going to explain throughout this paper.

Conclusion

            To sum up, we are going to show all the main information that we have provided throughout this paper and the conclusions that we have reach during its composition.

            Nowadays almost everyone knows who was Shakespeare and have read or have seen any of his works. He is one of the most famous authors of the history and some of the sentences of some of his works such as “To be or not to be, that’s the question” have been used for many people along the years. One of the characteristics that have probably helped to construct this well known of Shakespeare is that he portrays universal values in his works, such as religion, gender, love, moral or power. Thus we have chosen one of his earlier comedies, The Taming of the Shrew, as an example to show in this essay some of these universal values that can be understood all over the world and in all times.

            On the one hand, one of the issues that Shakespeare reflected in The Taming of the Shrew is the marriage and its economic reasons. We have observed that in the Elizabethan period relationships of love and the marriages between men and women were not based in the inner passions of the couple, but they were produced depending on economic interests. One of the examples that explained this is that Lucentio finally marries Bianca after demonstrating Baptista he was rich enough for his daughter. In addition as we explained before, these values are universal and understood nowadays because, despite today this kind of marriages are not usual and everyone can marry whoever they want this kind of economic marriage still exists.

            Moreover social status affected relationships as well. It was emphasized that relationships, both marriages and frienship should be happen between people of the same social status, so that they could be sure that anyone would be with another kind of person of a lower status with less money than the other. Even today as we see in the adaptation of the BBC, this importance of social status is still present with the example of the pre-marriage contract.

            In addition the position of women is one of the issues dealt with in this essay. In its section we have analysed the way women were treated within the patriarchal society of Elizabethan period, the way women were subjugated to men, and the difficulties they had to suffer. In contrast, in the adaptation of Shakespea-RE Told the position of women is quite different because it is based on the way of thinking of the 21th century. However despite we can see some features in the comedy that depict women as inferior or tamed by men, Shakespeare is just trying to make audience, through ridiculous and humorous scenes between both women and men, think about the unfair treatment of women during the Elizabethan time. As Ben Johnson said referring to Shakespeare, ‘He was not for an age but for all times’.

Bibliography

Ackroyd, P. (2006) The Complete Works of William Shakespeare. Glasgow: HarperCollins Publishers.

Aspinall, D. (2002) The Taming of the Shrew: Critical Essays and Theater Reviews [online] available from <http://books.google.es/books?id=K3fhDlRxFvQC&pg=PA104&lpg=PA104&dq=Ann+Barton+the+taming+of+the+shrew&source=bl&ots=lfFpHukISj&sig=45eI9q64Tu9qRFjRbap8bs7Kgss&hl=es&sa=X&ei=gfRyUPLzMqXb0QW414CoCA&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=Ann%20Barton%20the%20taming%20of%20the%20shrew&f=false> [07 October 2012]

Barbara A. Mowat and Paul Werstine. The Taming of the Shrew. Folger Shakespeare Library, 1992. Web. 8 Nov. 2010

Best, Michael “The Education of Girls” Shakespeare’s Life and Times. Internet Shakespeare Editions

Elizabethan.org (2011) Life in Elizabethan England [online] available from<http://www.elizabethan.org/compendium/index.html> [07 October 2012]

Encyclopedia Britannica (2011) Encyclopedia Britannica’s Guide to Shakespeare [online] available from < http://www.britannica.com/shakespeare/article-232318> [07 October 2012]

Gray, Terry A. The Taming of the Shrew. 25 April 1998.

Internet Shakespeare Editions (2011) Shakespeare’s life and Times [online] available from <http://internetshakespeare.uvic.ca/Library/SLT/intro/index.html> [08 October 2012]

Johnston, Ian. Critical Approaches to Shakespeare: Some Initial Observations. May 1999, November 2001

Ornstein, R. () Re-Visions of Shakespeare: Essays in Honor of Robert Ornstein [online] available from <http://books.google.es/books?id=BRGBAPYOibMC&pg=PA54&lpg=PA54&dq=Ann+Barton+the+taming+of+the+shrew&source=bl&ots=KgCM5qQ3e0&sig=mk-_074kCeKT7lS0OveFh197Bmg&hl=es&sa=X&ei=gfRyUPLzMqXb0QW414CoCA&ved=0CDoQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=Ann%20Barton%20the%20taming%20of%20the%20shrew&f=false>

 

Oxford Dictionaries (2012) “Shrew” [online] available from <http://oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/shrew?q=shrew> [08 October 2012]

The Guardian (2012) «The Taming of the Shrew: This is not a woman being crushed» [online] available from

<http://www.guardian.co.uk/stage/2012/jan/17/taming-of-the-shrew-rsc> [08 October 2012]

Thorne, S. (2003) Shakespeare: Advocate for Women in the Taming of the Shrew  [online] available from <http://www.hsu.edu/uploadedFiles/Faculty/Academic_Forum/2003-4/2003-4AFShakespeare.pdf> [09 October 2012]

Wikipedia (2012) The Taming of the Shrew [online] available from <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Taming_of_the_Shrew> [07 October 2012]

Wikipedia (2012) Shakespeare [online] available from <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shakespeare> [07 October 2012]

Misogynistic view

            As Hall stated, “I don’t think Shakespeare was being misogynistic in portraying female subjugation, but questioning the values of society. He’s challenging an audience’s expectations of how a woman is supposed to behave. What if, as a human being, she doesn’t want to roll over, as was expected in Shakespeare’s day? I actually think he’s championing the woman’s rights» (The Guardian: 2012).

            This early comedy of Shakespeare has brought with itself some discussions about the point of view of Shakespeare about women. Some critics and academics have spent much of the past century denouncing it as barbarous, offensive and misogynistic (The Guardian: 2012). However there are other opinions of many critics who defend the ideas of Hall explained above.

            The Taming of the Shrew is portraying the image of Katherine as a bad behaved, headstrong and wild woman. Every people that surround her think she is mad and rude and that she doesn’t act as a lady. However she gives the impression of a shrew just because she doesn’t accept to act as the woman she should be according to the patriarchal society of the Elizabethan time, she doesn’t want to accept the social roles imposed by the time. Women at that period were repressed by men so the only weapon of defense they had was their voice. In that attempt of defending herself of what she doesn’t want to be, she seems to be a rude woman and people though her behavior was unnatural of a proper woman.

            On the other hand, Shakespeare develops the character of Petruchio as an example of a patriarchal husband whose function is to tam his shrewish wife with some abusive methods. In depicting these outrageous characteristics of both Petruchio and Kate, Shakespeare creates in his work numerous humoristic moments. These ones call the attention of the audience producing in them the reaction of reconsidering the role of women in society and the treatment of them because the ridiculous moments they can observe between them can’t be the good ones of a love relationship between a wife and a husband. (Thorne:2003)

            Furthermore Shakespeare is trying to make the audience realise how unfair is the way in which this patriarchal society judges women. When Katherine acts different as she should do, or she speaks with rude words or she treats some people with arrogance, she is called a shrew, an unnatural woman, a wild lady. However when Petruchio starts to act in the same way with her after the wedding, and leaves her at the house without letting her sleep or eat, he is just treated as a good husband who is taming his shrewish wife, like he is just doing what he has to do. So with this example Shakespeare tries to show the audience the unfair of depicting both characters completely different when they are really doing the same.

PETRUCHIO: That is, to watch her, as we watch these kites

That bate and beat and will not be obedient.

She ate no meat today, nor none shall eat.

Last night she slept not, nor tonight she shall not.

As with the meat, some undeservèd fault

I’ll find about the making of the bed,

And here I’ll fling the pillow, there the bolster,

This way the coverlet, another way the sheets.

Ay, and amid this hurly I intend

That all is done in reverend care of her.

And, in conclusion, she shall watch all night,

And if she chance to nod I’ll rail and brawl,

And with the clamor keep her still awake.

This is a way to kill a wife with kindness,

And thus I’ll curb her mad and headstrong humor.

He that knows better how to tame a shrew,

Now let him speak; ’tis charity to show.

(4, I, 131-147)

            So that Shakespeare, despite not having the exactly same point of view about the marriage of the 21th century, he was already at his time defending the right of women both inside the marriage and in society. With the satire of this comedy he is putting into question the subjugation women suffered by their husbands.

Introduction

         ‘Shakespeare embodies universal values and has something to say to all people at all times and in all places’ (Eaglestone 2000:67). Thanks to this sentence we can state the importance of Shakespeare’s plays today. Almost four hundred years after Shakespeare’s death the ideals that he wanted to show to the public are still remembered. The vast majority of his works are taught at schools, politicians and speakers use many phrases from any of Shakespeare’s plays to say them in their speeches and everyone knows at least one of the works written by him. One reason why this happens is that Shakespeare discusses and presents in his works universal values that make that his works can be understood in the 16th century as well as in the 21th century. He wrote about issues such as gender, social position, love or stereotypes of society. Obviously four centuries later there are some differences in how the society understood these issues in that period and the way we understand them now. However despite this, when adaptations of the Shakespeare’s plays are made to present time barely any of these values has to be changed to the current audience because they can be understood. For this reason, the essay will present some examples of how the Shakespeare’s play The Taming of the Shrew shows the values of the Elizabethan era and at the same time how these issues are also relevant currently as seen in contemporary adaptations of the play.

The position of women

             Another of the values represented in Shakespeare’s plays is the position of women in society. During that time women were treated inferior to men. From childhood they were taught to obey the orders of men in the house and they did not have the same rights as men. If they ever disobeyed orders of any male member of the family, they were punished because that was seen as a crime according to what religion told them. Women could not inherit the tittles that their fathers had, but these passed from father to son. In contrast, the queen at that time in England was a woman and in addition she was unmarried. This happened because there was no choice when the father and the brother of Elizabeth I died. Nowadays the concept of women in society has changed considerably thanks to the struggle of women to show that we have the same rights and duties as men, because after all we are both, women and men, people. However there are still some remnants of the old patriarchal ideology. Today women can make decisions alone without the necessity of help of any man and can also access the important jobs as ministers or prime minister. (Internet Shakespeare Editions: 2011)

              There are examples of the difference between the women of the Elizabethan era and the women in the 20th in the Shakespeare’s play The Taming of the Shrew and its adaptation to television made by the BBC in 2005. In the theatre play we can see how women are relegated to second place. Baptista, the father of Bianca and Katherine exercise the authority and is in charge of finding a husband for them. Moreover if he cannot find any man that wants to marry his oldest daughter he will not allow the youngest to do so. In addition even though the main character is a woman, the man is who finally have the power and dominates as happened at that time. The title of the play already gives us an idea of how society in that moment saw the women, Katherine is called the shrew, which is the way that are called the women who are nonconformist and a bit different (oxforddictionaries:2012).

              In the TV adaptation of the play we can see how the role of women is different. Kate has an important job in British society, she is politician and she wants to become the leader of the opposition with the aim of becoming the prime minister. Bianca is a famous model who is very successful throughout the world. Moreover a big change is that the character of Baptista in the play is done by the mother of the girls in the mini-series. The fact that is the mother and not the father who appears in the film with Katherine and Bianca shows us that currently the 16th century patriarchal society no longer exists and it is not only the father who can make decisions about their daughters but also mother helping and giving advice to their daughters about their lives. In addition unlike the play, Bianca is going to flirt with Lucentio, which also shows that nowadays does not exist the concept that it is man who has to be a gallant and conquer the woman, but she can also take the initiative to do it. Despite this the end of the movie is the same, Petruchio tame the shrew by treating her the same way as she treats others.

              However this ending has been asked and studied  because it is not clear if Katherine really gets tamed at the end by Petruchio or if she is just acting when she speaks her last monologue.

“Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,

Thy head, thy sovereign . . .

Such duty as the subject owes the prince,

Even such a woman oweth to her husband,

And when she is froward, peevish, sullen, sour,

And not obedient to his honest will,

What is she but a foul contending rebel

And graceless traitor to her loving lord?

I am ashamed that women are so simple [foolish]

To offer war where they should kneel for peace,

Or seek for rule, supremacy, and sway,

When they are bound to serve, love, and obey.”

(5.2.148-66).

              That is, Shakespeare is not defending the value of inferiority of women, but just trying to show the injustices that women had to suffer in this time beacause wether or not she really belives what she says in the example above, she has to tell it in order to behave as a proper wife. We will explain this issue in the part of the paper where we want to debate the possible or not misogynistic view of Shakespeare.

Differences among social status

              Another value that Shakespeare emphasizes in his works is the importance of social status, which reflects the need of the time that relationships must be between people of the same social class. In The Taming of the Shrew, we can see how Baptista asks Bianca’s suitors how much could they pay for her if they were married to know their purchasing power with the aim of not allow his daughter to marry someone with less money than her and that belongs to a lower class. (Elizabethan.org:2011) The Elizabethan society was structured according to hierarchical power pyramid so that difference between high and low status were obviously present. Nobility was at the top of this hyerarchical structure and rich people were in a high possition in it as well. On the other hand poor people were at the bottom of the pyramid and many times they worked as servants of the rich people and have to obey their lords.

GRUMIO: Nay, ’tis no matter, sir, what he ‘leges in Latin. If this be

not a lawful case for me to leave his service—look you,

sir: he bid me knock him and rap him soundly, sir. Well,

was it fit for a servant to use his master so, being

perhaps, for aught I see, two-and-thirty, a pip out?

Whom, would to God, I had well knocked at first,

Then had not Grumio come by the worst.

PETRUCHIO: A senseless villain, good Hortensio.

I bade the rascal knock upon your gate

And could not get him for my heart to do it.

GRUMIO: Knock at the gate? O heavens! Spake you not these

words plain: “Sirrah, knock me here, rap me here, knock

me well, and knock me soundly”? And come you now

with “knocking at the gate”?

PETRUCHIO: Sirrah, begone or talk not, I advise you.

(1, II, 23-30)

              In modern adaptations of the works we can see how this importance in terms of social status still remains relevant today. In the television adaptation we can also see an example of this when at the end Bianca asks Lucentio to sign a prenuptial agreement before their wedding so she assures herself that if their marriage fails she keeps her money.

              In addition Shakespeare creates most of the comedy’s humourous situations thanks to the ability of creating false realities with the characters by acting themselves as other different person as they really are. The funniest ones are when a low status character has to interpret a higher status character than himself or the other way round. We can see this device first in the introduction when Christopher Sly is forced to believe that he is someone he is not.

SLY: Am I a lord, and have I such a lady?

Or do I dream? Or have I dreamed till now?

I do not sleep: I see, I hear, I speak.

I smell sweet savors and I feel soft things.

Upon my life, I am a lord indeed

And not a tinker, nor Christopher Sly.

Well, bring our lady hither to our sight,

And once again, a pot o’ the smallest ale.

(induction, II, 53-60)

            Later on during the rest of the comedy almost all the characters in The Taming of the Shrew adopt in a certain point of the comedy a role to create a funny fake situation such as Christopher Sly being a king, Tranio pretending to be Lucentio, Lucentio as Cambio, Hortensio acting as Litio or even Tranio convincing a man to portray Vincentio.

LUCENTIO: (as CAMBIO) Fiddler, forbear. You grow too forward, sir.

Have you so soon forgot the entertainment

Her sister Katherina welcomed you withal?

HORTENSIO: (as LITIO) But, wrangling pedant, this is

The patroness of heavenly harmony.

Then give me leave to have prerogative,

And when in music we have spent an hour,

Your lecture shall have leisure for as much.

LUCENTIO:(as CAMBIO) Preposterous ass, that never read so far

To know the cause why music was ordained.

Was it not to refresh the mind of man

After his studies or his usual pain?

Then give me leave to read philosophy

And, while I pause, serve in your harmony.

HORTENSIO:(as LITIO) Sirrah, I will not bear these braves of thine.

(3, I, 1-15)

 

Marriage and its economic reasons

         In this Shakespearian comedy, The Taming of the Shrew, we can observe one of the principal values of the Elizabethan era, the economic reasons of marriages. In the play we can clearly observe how Shakespeare emphasised  how factors such as money, land or power were the main concern of people when arranging a wedding. Thus courtship is understood more as an imposed game of Elizabethan society than a real process in which oneself can show the inner passion of love to the person loved. In addition courtship and the arrangement of marriage do not only concern the “lovers” but the parents, the servants and the friends as well as we can see in the Shakespearian comedy The taming of the Shrew with the example of how Katherine and Bianca’ suitors have to demonstrate their father, Baptista, the dowry each one can bring to the marriage, the one who provides the best one is the one who achieves the woman.

TRANIO: (as LUCENTIO) Then go with me to make the matter good.

This, by the way, I let you understand:

My father is here looked for every day

To pass assurance of a dower in marriage

‘Twixt me and one Baptista’s daughter here.

In all these circumstances I’ll instruct you.

Go with me to clothe you as becomes you.

(4, II, 118-125)

          So marriage becomes a negotiation in which money is the most important thing in it. We can observe this importance of money with the example of the marriage between Lucentio and Bianca, because he finally wins Bianca, but after convincing her father that he is rich enough for her and that he can contribute to the marriage a lot of money, however if Hortensio had convinced Baptista with a larger sum of money, she would have married him instead of Lucentio. In addition another clear example of marriage as an economical institution is the reason which move Petruchio to marry Kate, which is money. He wants to marry a rich women and he does not care about if he likes his future wife.

PETRUCHIO: Such wind as scatters young men through the world

To seek their fortunes farther than at home,

Where small experience grows. But in a few,

Signior Hortensio, thus it stands with me:

Antonio, my father, is deceased,

And I have thrust myself into this maze,

Happily to wive and thrive as best I may.

Crowns in my purse I have and goods at home,

And so am come abroad to see the world.

HORTENSIO: Petruchio, shall I then come roundly to thee

And wish thee to a shrewd, ill-favored wife?

Thou’dst thank me but a little for my counsel;

And yet I’ll promise thee she shall be rich,

And very rich. But thou’rt too much my friend,

And I’ll not wish thee to her.

PETRUCHIO: Signior Hortensio, ’twixt such friends as we

Few words suffice. And therefore, if thou know

One rich enough to be Petruchio’s wife,

As wealth is burden of my wooing dance,

Be she as foul as was Florentius’ love,

As old as Sibyl and as curst and shrewd

As Socrates’ Xanthippe, or a worse,

She moves me not, or not removes at least

Affection’s edge in me, were she as rough

As are the swelling Adriatic seas.

I come to wive it wealthily in Padua;

If wealthily, then happily in Padua.

(1, II, 36-62)

               In this courtship game, however, we realise that women are treated like objects that can be bought and sold rather than as human beings and this is one of the consequences of living in the patriarchal society of the Elizabethan period. (Elizabethan.org:2008)

               Moreover one of the features that we can found in the comedy is that Shakespeare does not only show us the process of marriage  ending with the wedding as he usually does, but The Taming of the Shrew continues with the story after the lovers marry so we can see how they are after this process and how they act as being husband and wife. It is during this time when the process of taming is produced and one of the main reasons of it is because a woman controlling a man as Kate did, is considered against what is socially established. (Encyclopedia Britannica: 2012)

              Happily this issue has changed nowadays and each person can marry the one he or she wants, and the romance is moved by love and not by material things such as money. However this does not mean that it always happens this way.   Sometimes among people with a high social status this features are still present. We can also see this idea in the adaptation to television made by the BBC in 2005 «ShakespeaRe-Told» The Taming of the Shrew. In this mini-series Katherine marries Petruchio to achieve leadership in her political party. Some people inside the party advise her that producing a change in her life and marrying someone would give her greater prestige and this way becoming the leader of the opposition and later to being prime minister of England.

Bibliography

Wordsworth View of Nature, accessed on 20/11/2011: http://books.google.es/books?id=LQs9AAAAIAAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=wordsworth+nature&hl=es&ei=8tnGToexO47NswaUs4STBw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CC4Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false

The Norton Anthology of English Literature, Tintern Abbey, Tourism and Romantic Landscape, accessed on 23/11/2011: http://www.wwnorton.com/college/english/nael/romantic/topic_1/welcome.htm

BBC History, The Wordsworths and the Cult of Nature, By Pamela Woof, Last updated 2011-02-17, accessed on 20/11/2011: http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/empire_seapower/wordsworths_01.shtml

Poet Seers, Poetry of William Wordsworth, accessed on 22/11/2011: http://www.poetseers.org/the_romantics/william_wordsworth/poetry_william_wordsworth/

The Victorian Web, Nature, Shelley, and Wordsworth, by Amelia Warren ’93, accessed on 24/11/2011: http://www.victorianweb.org/previctorian/ww/nature2.html

The Victorian Web, Nature in Shelley and Wordsworth, by Chris Drummond ’93 (English 32, 1989), accessed on 24/11/2011: http://www.victorianweb.org/previctorian/ww/nature3.html

YouTube, William Wordsworth – Documentary (Part 1), by ImpossibleParadise, accessed on 23/11/2011: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PdDHzBq7h4

YouTube, The Romantics – BBC documentary – Nature (2005), by shinobirastafari, accessed on 23/11/2011: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhOyI-SjU-g&feature=related

Wikipedia, William Wordsworth, accessed on 22/11/2011: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Wordsworth#First_publication_and_Lyrical_Ballads

Bartleby, William Wordsworth, accessed on 20/11/2011: http://www.bartleby.com/145/

KoR, Wordsworth celebration of man and nature, by Caleb Williams, accessed 23/11/2011: http://www.sol.com.au/kor/6_03.htm

Shawn Rider Writings, Wordsworth and Coleridge: Emotion , Imagination and Complexity, accessed on 24/11/2011: http://www.wdog.com/rider/writings/wordsworth_and_coleridge.htm

« Página anterior — Página siguiente »